Why Everything You Think You Know About Teen Moms Is Wrong: Lessons from ‘The Girls Who Grew Big’

Have you ever stopped to think how much misinformation surrounds teen pregnancy and young motherhood? For years, stereotypes have shaped public opinion, often painting teen moms as failures or victims of circumstance. But what if those views are not just outdated—they’re downright harmful? Leila Mottley’s recent novel, The Girls Who Grew Big, is shaking up these misconceptions by telling raw, authentic stories of three young women navigating pregnancy and motherhood in a small Florida town. It’s a narrative that doesn’t just humanize teen moms but reframes their experience as empowering and complex.

In this post, we’ll dive deep into the themes Mottley explores, the societal assumptions she confronts, and how her work ties into the growing trend of at-home pregnancy options that symbolize empowerment and autonomy for all parents-to-be—including teens.


The Power of Storytelling to Challenge Stereotypes

Mottley’s novel is more than just a story. It’s an extension of her work as a doula, giving voice to young mothers whose experiences are often ignored or dismissed. By following three protagonists, she highlights their resilience, struggles, and the community dynamics shaping their journeys. It’s a stark contrast to the typical media portrayals of teen mothers as irresponsible or doomed.

The NPR piece discussing The Girls Who Grew Big (https://www.npr.org/2025/07/09/nx-s1-5461066/leila-mottley-the-girls-who-grew-big-nightcrawling) points out how Mottley’s work centers on the nuance of these women’s lives — from emotional complexity to social support systems. This reminds us that pregnancy at any age, but especially for young women, involves navigating not just biology, but also a tangled web of emotions, choices, and socio-economic realities.


Why This Matters for At-Home Pregnancy Methods

Here’s where things get interesting for the audience of HomePregNavigator. More people—including younger individuals—are looking toward alternatives to traditional clinical pregnancy options. At-home insemination kits, like those from MakeAMom, provide discreet, affordable, and user-friendly ways to approach conception. These kits are designed with a deep understanding that everyone’s needs are unique:

  • The CryoBaby kit for users working with low-volume or frozen sperm
  • The Impregnator kit tailored for low motility sperm
  • The BabyMaker kit for those with conditions like vaginismus or sensitivities

The accessibility and empowerment offered by such kits echo the themes in Mottley’s novel — autonomy, control, and the dismantling of stigma.


Data-Driven Insights: Empowerment Through Accessibility

MakeAMom reports an average success rate of 67% among clients using their home insemination systems, a remarkable figure that challenges assumptions about the necessity of expensive clinic-based procedures. This is crucial for young people—who may face financial, emotional, or social barriers to traditional fertility care—and aligns with the broader cultural shift toward self-managed reproductive health.

But it’s not just about success rates. The discreet packaging and reusability of MakeAMom’s kits represent thoughtful design informed by real user needs, supporting privacy (often a big concern for younger parents) and sustainability.


What Can We Learn from ‘The Girls Who Grew Big’ About Supporting Young Parents?

  • Listen to nuanced stories: Teen motherhood isn’t a monolith. Each person’s experience deserves respect and understanding.
  • Promote autonomy: Offering accessible, cost-effective at-home pregnancy options empowers individuals to take control of their reproductive futures.
  • Challenge stigma: Breaking down stereotypes creates environments where young parents can thrive without judgment.
  • Support mental and emotional wellness: As Mottley’s novel shows, pregnancy and parenting are as much emotional journeys as they are physical ones.

Final Thoughts

In a world where young mothers are still too often underestimated or misunderstood, The Girls Who Grew Big reminds us that storytelling can be a powerful catalyst for change. At the same time, the rise of innovative at-home conception methods, like those from MakeAMom, marks a tangible step toward reproductive equity and empowerment.

Are you ready to rethink what you know about teen pregnancy—and perhaps explore new ways to support yourself or someone you love on their pregnancy journey? Check out more about how discreet, effective, and empowering home insemination options can open new doors.

What’s your take on the intersection of literature, empowerment, and reproductive health? Drop your thoughts below — let’s get the conversation started!

Author

Priya Raman

Hello! I'm Priya, a women's health educator and advocate with a background in nursing. My journey began when I navigated my own at-home pregnancy experience, and ever since, I've been passionate about empowering others with accessible, clear information. I believe everyone deserves to feel confident in their pregnancy choices, and I'm here to help you make informed decisions every step of the way.