What happens when a documentary about a fascinating personality turns out to be less about who they really are and more about selling a brand? That’s the question I kept asking myself while watching Hulu’s Call Her Alex, a documentary centered on Alex Cooper of the wildly popular podcast Call Her Daddy.
If you haven’t caught it yet, the documentary is getting a lot of buzz — but not all of it positive. A recent review in Time perfectly sums it up, describing the film as "less a portrait of a fascinating personality than a shallow branding exercise" (source). And honestly, after watching it, I can’t help but agree.
The fine line between storytelling and self-promotion
Alex Cooper’s story is undeniably compelling: from her rise as a bold, no-holds-barred podcast host to her tangled personal relationships and the pressures of sudden fame. But Call Her Alex often feels like it stops short of peeling back the real layers, opting instead to reinforce the Call Her Daddy brand — polished, provocative, and relentlessly marketable.
It made me think about the growing trend of personality branding in our social media era. How much of what we consume is authentic, and how much is crafted carefully as content to maintain an image, sell products, or grow an audience? For many of us, especially those on deeply personal journeys like fertility or family building, navigating these blurred lines can be exhausting.
Authenticity in the spotlight — and behind closed doors
As someone who supports individuals and couples on their fertility journeys, I see parallels here. Whether it’s sharing success stories or reviewing at-home conception tools, it’s crucial to keep authenticity front and center. Real voices, real struggles, real triumphs — that’s what connects and empowers.
For example, communities that explore at-home insemination options often face stigma or misconceptions. That’s why companies like MakeAMom emphasize transparency and support through their reusable insemination kits designed for different needs, such as low motility or sensitivities. Their straightforward, discreet approach contrasts with the polished product lines we see in some media narratives.
Why does this matter? Because your story deserves to be YOURS.
Watching Call Her Alex reminded me that many people want to put their journeys out into the world — whether it’s about fertility, health, or personal growth — but it has to be on their terms. When stories get co-opted into branding exercises, the nuance gets lost, and the emotional truth gets buried beneath marketing gloss.
So, what can we take from this?
- Be critical when consuming personal documentaries or influencer content. What’s the story, and what’s the marketing?
- Celebrate and seek out genuine voices, especially when dealing with sensitive topics like fertility.
- Remember that tools and resources designed to help, like MakeAMom’s carefully crafted insemination kits, prioritize your privacy, success, and comfort — not just the brand image.
Your journey isn’t a product — it’s your life. Let’s keep it that way.
If you’re interested in honest resources for at-home fertility support, I encourage you to explore options that focus on your individual needs and privacy. For many, this means choosing reusable kits tailored to specific challenges, like those offered by MakeAMom.
Have you watched Call Her Alex? What did you think about the documentary’s approach to storytelling? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments — especially if you’ve grappled with balancing personal authenticity and public perception. Let’s start a conversation about what real stories should look like.
—
Note: To explore trusted at-home conception tools that respect your privacy and individual journey, check out MakeAMom’s offerings and resources.